Cygnet Brings Back ‘Cabaret’ and the Menacing Allure of Berlin in the Waning Days of the Weimar Republic

“Willkommen,” the upbeat opening song from Kander and Ebb’s musical Cabaret promises carefree escape from the real world’s problems. But the musical itself makes a trenchant case for the political realm’s inescapable consequences on the personal.

Cygnet Theatre has mounted yet another revival of this powerful theatrical spectacle, and Saturday’s striking opening night performance proved its heart-stopping relevance. Scenic designer Sean Fanning has turned the Theatre in Old Town into Berlin’s shady Kit Kat Klub, and Sean Murray’s incisive direction channels the menacing thrill of Germany on the eve of the Nazi coup.

Megan Carmitchel (left) & the Kit Kat Klub chorines [photo (c.) Ken Jacques]

As the Kit Kat Club’s manipulative emcee, Allen Lucky Weaver craftily enticed the audience into savoring his club’s pleasures, although his honeyed voice could not disguise the cynical snarl behind his welcome. Megan Carmitchel wisely took her time revealing the complex, contradictory layers of Sally Bowles, the English singer who stars on the club’s stage but regularly  strikes out with the men in her life. In her early song, “Don’t Tell Mama,” I thought her voice lacked presence, but when she got to “Maybe This Time,” she unleashed enough power to reveal her character’s acute desperation. As Sally’s world collapsed around her, Carmitchel’s manic, farewell reprise of “Cabaret” rivaled any soprano’s mad scene from grand opera.

Megan Carmitchel & Wil Bethmann [photo (c.) Ken Jacques]

In Cabaret’s urtext, the Berlin Stories of Christopher Isherwood, the author who visits Berlin in the waning Weimar Republic years is Isherwood himself, but Cabaret’s leading man is Cliff Bradshaw, a naive American writer. Will Bethmann gave Cliff an earnest veneer that his Berlin experiences quickly destroy, bringing out unsuspected warmth in both his character and his vocal allure. Linda Libby and Eddie Yaroch gave the musical’s secondary romantic pair, Fräulein Schneider and Herr Schultz, touching characterizations as the street violence of brownshirt thugs dissolved the proposed marriage of the middle-aged German woman and the older Jewish merchant.

As Max, the Kit Kat Klub’s manager, Luke H. Jacobs’ gruff authority worked well, and Erica Marie Weisz demonstrated that Fräulein Kost was much more than the stereotypical hooker with a heart of gold.

Considering the modest size of Cygnet’s stage, choreographer Katie Banville put her four Kit Kat chorines and their two male counterparts through their paces with constantly inventive dance routines that honored the period. Kelley Prendergast, Alyssa Anne Austin, Carolyn Lupin, and Tamara Rodriguez danced with polished ease and sang with gusto as the chorines. Trevor Cruse as Bobby and Marc Caro as Victor proved their dance acumen as well as their sexy allure as the Berlin beefcake that tempts Cliff out of his closeted gay identity.

Gerry Tonella as Ernst Ludwig deftly navigated the transition from Cliff’s friendly guide to underground Berlin and devoted English language student to strident Nazi Party member.

From sophisticated formal wear for upper class club patrons to the revealing costumes of the club’s sexy young entertainers, Zoë Trautmann has devised an array of costumes that evoke the period and clearly define its class strata.

Music Director Patrick Marion coaxed a fiery wall of sound—appropriately brass-dominated—from his band of six instrumentalists, and he proved a savvy interpreter of the musical style of the period as depicted in John Kander’s score. Kudos to trumpeter Alyssa Keene and trombonist Devin Blumworth for their vibrant solos and to Marion’s fleet work on the piano as he conducted the ensemble.

Cygent’s production of ‘Cabaret’ will run through September 4, 2022, at the Theatre in Old Town, 4044 Twiggs Ave. San Diego.

CABARET.program

Ken Herman

Ken Herman, a classically trained pianist and organist, has covered music for the San Diego Union, the Los Angeles Times' San Diego Edition, and for sandiego.com. He has won numerous awards, including first place for Live Performance and Opera Reviews in the 2017, the 2018, and the 2019 Excellence in Journalism Awards competition held by the San Diego Press Club. A Chicago native, he came to San Diego to pursue a graduate degree and stayed.Read more…

More Posts - Facebook

2 Comments

  1. Bill Eadie on August 3, 2022 at 12:52 am

    I am currently in Berlin, and a friend who lives here pointed out the Kit-Kat Club, calling it a “famous dive.” I’m sorry to miss this production, but I won’t be back in San Diego to see it, even with an extension.

  2. Amy Roth on August 22, 2022 at 9:44 am

    The show is brilliant and the cast was wonderful, but the acoustics at the Cygnet were terrible. The sound engineer must have been asleep at the wheel.
    At the performance I saw, the matinee on Sunday, August 21, many people in the audience aside from me were bothered because they couldn’t hear the principals, and even when they could hear them, they couldn’t understand the lyrics.

    Why have none of the reviews mentioned this serious lapse?

Leave a Comment